Forum
SEARCH FORUM:

Forum > Beauty

Facebook
Twitter
Googleplus
Guggu
Style_council
Guggu

I just wanted to know wich is more popular:pencil or liquid eyeliner?I’d say pencil,but I want to know other opinions.

posted about 7 years ago
BeckyBedbug
Style_council
BeckyBedbug

I much prefer liquid. I’ve used it for about 5 years now.

posted about 7 years ago
 
JazmB
Style_council
JazmB

Liquid. I can’t get close enough to my lashes when using a pencil, it looks very amateuristic on me.

posted about 7 years ago
 
Vintageholic
Style_council
Vintageholic

Liquid

posted about 7 years ago
 
KatieLikeMe
Style_council
KatieLikeMe

Liquid. Or gel/cream. But, I think liquid is probably a but more popular than that.

posted about 7 years ago
 
gizellemarion
New_user gizellemarion is new to Chictopia!

Make Her Feel Welcome with Chic Points
10 points - Become a fan
5 points - Vote her photos into the Style Gallery
1 point - Post a comment on her photos

When gizellemarion reaches 200 Chic Points, she will be in the Style Council!
gizellemarion

Liquid. It gives that nice finish if you’re used to applying them. But if not, you can always opt for the pencil.

posted about 7 years ago
 
sukavati
Style_council
sukavati

Liquid because I never put it on my waterline. The pencil tends to smear on the tops of my lids because I have oily lids. Lately I’ve been using the gel liner by Maybelline, which is pretty good.

posted about 7 years ago
 
ginanicolette
Style_council
ginanicolette

i love pencil but i know liquid is popular now

posted about 7 years ago
 
Guggu
Style_council
Guggu

Thank you all for the advices/opinions.I see the liquid eyeliner it`s very popular ,but I think I’ll stay with my ancient pencil:)Thanks again!

posted about 7 years ago
 
lindajudour
Style_council
lindajudour

I use liquid just because when using pencil it tends to smudge more because I have oily lids. The liquid ones keep my lines in place for hours.

posted about 7 years ago
 
PeachyPanda
Style_council
PeachyPanda

Liquid is great for a smudgeproof look but I do like pencil because I like to have that slightly smudged smokey effect.

posted almost 7 years ago
 
lalipops
Style_council
lalipops

I have that gel waterproof liner from Maybelline as well and I love it! But I use the pencil as well.

posted almost 7 years ago
 
rileighnuss
Style_council
rileighnuss

Pencil shows up best on the water line.
Liquid is best for lining above your top lashes.
Cream is best for everything! (Try MAKE UP FOR EVER Aqua Black or Tarte Cosmetics gel liner)

posted almost 7 years ago
 
itshayliebrooke
Style_council
itshayliebrooke

I prefer liquid. I use the Barry M Wink eyeliner pen and I love it. Its sort of a balance between liquid and pencil because its nice and smooth (its basically a felt tip makeup pen) but its not totally fake looking :)

posted almost 7 years ago
 
tightsandtea
Style_council
tightsandtea

I actually prefer gel/cream liners—as precise as liquid, with the benefit of being totally matte. I use the Tarte clay liner with a small angled liner brush.

but of the two, definitely liquid. you just can’t get bold, crisp eyeliner with pencils.

posted almost 7 years ago
 
SkinniMini
Style_council
SkinniMini

Liquid&gel..pencil for the lower lids

posted almost 7 years ago
 
tenthousandoutfits
Style_council
tenthousando...

gel and liquid! liquid eyeliner last for a very long time.

posted almost 7 years ago
 
stylesplash
Style_council
stylesplash

I’d used a pencil for years until I tried Maybelline gel liner, and now I use it every day. I still use a pencil if I wear eyeliner on my lower lids, but the gel lasts longer and doesn’t smudge.

posted almost 7 years ago
 
Crisss
Style_council
Crisss

i prefer pencil

posted almost 7 years ago
 
Crisss
Style_council
Crisss

it looks more natural

posted almost 7 years ago
 
Icelandic_Beauty
New_user Icelandic_Beauty is new to Chictopia!

Make Her Feel Welcome with Chic Points
10 points - Become a fan
5 points - Vote her photos into the Style Gallery
1 point - Post a comment on her photos

When Icelandic_Beauty reaches 200 Chic Points, she will be in the Style Council!
Icelandic_Be...

I like to use gel or liquid

posted almost 7 years ago
 
jackiex35
New_user jackiex35 is new to Chictopia!

Make Her Feel Welcome with Chic Points
10 points - Become a fan
5 points - Vote her photos into the Style Gallery
1 point - Post a comment on her photos

When jackiex35 reaches 200 Chic Points, she will be in the Style Council!
jackiex35

i love liquid and crayon (liquid in a pencil form) just creates such a better effect

posted almost 7 years ago
 
jackiex35
New_user jackiex35 is new to Chictopia!

Make Her Feel Welcome with Chic Points
10 points - Become a fan
5 points - Vote her photos into the Style Gallery
1 point - Post a comment on her photos

When jackiex35 reaches 200 Chic Points, she will be in the Style Council!
jackiex35

i love liquid and crayon (liquid in a pencil form) just creates such a better effect

posted almost 7 years ago
 
jackiex35
New_user jackiex35 is new to Chictopia!

Make Her Feel Welcome with Chic Points
10 points - Become a fan
5 points - Vote her photos into the Style Gallery
1 point - Post a comment on her photos

When jackiex35 reaches 200 Chic Points, she will be in the Style Council!
jackiex35

i love liquid and crayon (liquid in a pencil form) just creates such a better effect

posted almost 7 years ago
 
LyssBlondish
Style_council
LyssBlondish

liquid.

posted almost 7 years ago
REPLY TO DISCUSSION
Please log in. Don't have an account? Sign up here.
Continue_with_facebook
or login below
Username
Password